Justia Lawyer Rating
MH Badge
Super Lawyers
Louisiana State Bar Association
State Bar of Texas
Illinois State Bar Association
United States Patent and Trademark Office


In In Re Maatita, 900 F. 3d. 1369 (2018), the inventor filed a design patent application for a shoe sole that included only a single, two-dimensional, plan-view drawing of the shoe. The patent examiner at the USPTO rejected the application as not satisfying the enablement and definiteness requirements of 35 U.S.C. §112. The examiner concluded that the two-dimensional drawing was subject to multiple interpretations of the depth and contour of the claimed elements. The Patent Trial and Appeal Board affirmed the examiner’s rejection. The U.S. Court of Appeal for the Federal Circuit reversed, concluding that even though shoe bottoms can have three-dimensional aspects, their ornamental design can be adequately discerned from a two-dimensional, plan drawing; therefore, Maatita’s two-dimensional drawing clearly demonstrated the perspective from which the shoe bottom should be viewed. Furthermore, the court further concluded that Maatita’s failure to disclose all possible depth choices would not preclude an ordinary observer from understanding the claimed design, which was adequately represented in the two-dimensional drawing.

Client Reviews
Tolar Harrigan & Morris is one of the very best Attorney groups I have worked with in the last 25 years. Smart and very responsive.. John G.
Compassionate - not an attribute I would have originally associated with a law firm. Tolar, Harrigan, & Morris was that and much more. From the first point of contact, it was apparent that this team was not only highly competent in their craft, but also genuine and determined to produce positive results. I have said it many times and will continue to say that if we would have chosen another firm, our results would have been much different. With an over-the-top work ethic, it is no surprise that we prevailed. My family and I could not have asked for a better equipped firm and are very happy with the results. Sherie N.
I want to leave a review for Tolar Harrigan & Morris LLC. My partner and I came to them after a lot of research on who to proceed with regarding our Patent. Not only did Kenneth Tolar assist us with successfully filing our Patent. But in addition, he helped us secure even more protection on our patent with additional features + more. His professionalism, recommendations, attitude, work ethic, communication and experience in his field is REMARKABLE. Jay K.
I’ve used this office for many years now and have a great relationship. They are honest and very effective in this field. This office is my “Go To” for ALL my patents and trademark needs. Call them today and see what I’m talking about. Ask for Ken. Ray A.